Rating: 7 out of 10.

Vengeance isn’t justice.

I’m starting to think “Daredevil: Born Again” might be too Catholic for me. I never thought that while watching the Netflix iteration of Marvel’s (flagship?) television series, though. Matt Murdock (Charlie Cox) and his Defenders friends were dealing with adversaries who would always ultimately end up in jail or dead. Justice was served regardless of his guilt. That guilt was actually Matt’s part of evening the scales. But all that has changed now.

Why? Because this reboot is as much Wilson Fisk’s (Vincent D’Onofrio) story as it is Murdock’s. Both actors were instrumental to keeping the property alive. Both serve as executive producers. So, death is off the table and jail is merely a layover to be rectified by Dario Scardapane and his team of writers. Sure, it’s a positive in the sense that hero and villain are on even footing when stakes are involved, but are they really stakes when the endgame is forever the start of a new bout?

I probably wouldn’t mind asking these questions if this season released as the fifth chapter of the original run in 2020. Back then Trump was still more or less curtailed by the law and order of historical precedent. He still sought to keep up the appearance of legitimacy even as he worked behind the scenes to strip the country for parts. Now, though? With the media in his pocket, his own private army, and talk of prosecuting detractors for treason? Reality has caught up.

This truth is never more prevalent that the season finale “The Southern Cross” due to how it depicts its everyman revolution. You cannot watch a group of angry citizens charge into a New York City courthouse calling for the head of Mayor Fisk without thinking about January 6th. Except, of course, that these people are on the right side of history. But what’s stopping the real criminal insurrectionists from seeing themselves on-screen instead? Or others from yelling hypocrisy?

It’s a slippery slope because we can no longer separate fact from fiction as easily as we could pre-2021. We don’t have trusted objective voices explaining the context and differences. We only have opportunists seeking any which way to exploit popular culture to better support their own ambitions. Because those paying attention know that Fisk’s task force is ICE. But those already too far gone wrongly see them as what will replace ICE if democrats regain power.

And that brings me to the Catholicism of it all and the main through line running down this season’s middle so it can serve as an epilogue to what happened during its troubled predecessor. Murdock is constantly talking about grace and mercy to keep himself from becoming Frank Castle. He keeps reminding himself about it as well as partner/girlfriend (finally) Karen Page (Deborah Ann Woll). He uses it to directly sermonize to the audience too.

There’s a difference, though, between giving a guy like Lionel McCoy (Nathan Wallace) a second chance and letting Benjamin Poindexter (Wilson Bethel) off the hook. Don’t get me wrong. I love the complexity that arises from the comparison. Asking yourself how circumstances lead someone to violence and how grace can teach them another way. But there’s also a difference from providing that to someone who wants it and someone who doesn’t.

It’s why you can’t just gloss over the fact that Matt asking Karen not to kill Poindexter for her own soul’s sake is different than asking himself not to kill Fisk. Saving his own soul aside, the former is a hired hand working through the strings of manipulation to come out the other side. The latter is a remorseless monster actively trying to destroy beauty and decency in order to force his own vision for personal grandeur onto the world by enslaving it to his whims.

This moral gray turns red as the show approaches a compromise of mutual exile to prevent the murder of a principal character and set-up an inevitable third go-round. It’s a dangerous precedent to accept on-screen considering the carnage Fisk is finally allowed to wreak let alone our current political climate. To offer a mad man covered in his victims’ blood amnesty? No way. We’re beyond Ford pardoning Nixon for “peace.” The door to an encore must be slammed shut.

Again, though. This thinking is less about the content of the show and more about the context of its mirror. To watch it in a vacuum is a different story because it allows you to embrace the messaging and narrative propulsion on its own terms rather than a blueprint or treatise on reality. In that respect, this season is much better than the first—and not just because it’s not trying to marry two different styles so Marvel isn’t eating the entire budget twice.

This eight-episode arc is fully serialized and coherent. There are no subplots (Margarita Levieva and Camila Rodriguez still deal with the ramifications of Muse and Hector Ayala’s deaths, but within the main plot’s confines) or field trips (sorry, “With Interest” fans, although Bullseye’s opening to “Gloves Off” is great). Everything is moving towards a courtroom showdown between Murdock and Fisk to either topple the latter from his perch or further entrench him upon it.

Newcomers Matthew Lillard and Lili Taylor are therefore less adversarial than pawns as his Mr. Charles and her Governor McCaffrey push Fisk’s buttons. And returning actors Arty Froushan, Michael Gandolfini, and Genneya Walton aren’t getting their own story thread to pursue as much as working through the loyalty oaths and betrayals inherent to the political machine (albeit with mortal stakes). I absolutely loved the guerrilla op-eds with a Fisk-mask caricature.

Give Scardapane a lot of credit for saving the show by crafting those bookends to season one last year and now finding a way to bring that arc to completion in a way that sets up a ton of potential drama for season three. It’s not a full-blown self-contained success, but it effectively gets things on track for a fresh start with some surprising public revelations (and the re-introduction of two former Defenders). It’s less trial drama and a lot more bloody action and profanity.


(L-R) Matt Murdock/Daredevil (Charlie Cox) and Ben Pointsdexter/Bullesye (Wilson Bethel) in Marvel Television’s DAREDEVIL: BORN AGAIN SEASON 2, exclusively on Disney+. Photo by Jojo Whilden. © 2026 MARVEL.

Leave a comment